Text size
DefenseNewsGlobal Security.
Strategic Insight.
Breaking News

Mistral row: France risks losing Rafale contract in India

France risks losing a contract to supply 126 fighter jets to India due to its refusal to deliver Mistral-class ships to Russia, a leading French analyst told the Delovoi Peterburg website. French officials said this week that they will not deliver the first Mistral-class amphibious warship that Russia had ordered as part of a $1.7 billion agreement for weapons sale.
Defence, Defence News, Military, Indian Navy, India, US, Russia, china, DRDO, france, Germany, IAF, Japan, Philippines, UK, Australia, Dassault Rafale, Boing, Finmeccanica, DassaultThe biggest repercussion would be a loss of reputation for France as a reliable supplier, Arnaud Dubien, a Russia research associate at the Institut de relations Internationales et Strategiques said. “Officials from the French Ministry of Defence, in private conversations acknowledge that if they fail to deliver the Mistral to Russia, then France will lose its contract to supply 126 fighter jets to India,” Dubien said.

Dubien believes that the decision of French President Francois Hollande, to suspend the delivery of the Mistral, is not final, and was taken under tremendous pressure from the United States and Germany. He added that a final decision would be taken by November on the delivery of the warships, and a lot would depend on how the situation in Ukraine panned out.

A source in the Indian Defence Ministry said that India was “watching the developments closely.” The source added it was too early to say if this would factor into the government’s decision to sign a contract. “When such a large amount of money is paid and then a supplier uses geopolitics to delay or suspend deliveries, it does raise eyebrows,” the source, who was not authorised to talk to the media, said. The Indian Ministry of Defence could not be immediately reached for official comment.

India is continuing its final negotiations for acquiring 126 French Rafale fighters in a deal that would cost around $22 billion. France’s Dassault Aviation won a bid to supply India with Medium Multi-Role Combat Aircrafts and a final contract is being dubbed as the “mother of all deals,” by many sections of the Indian media. Russia, Britain, the U.S. and Sweden have all made attempts to re-enter the race to sell their aircrafts.

Indian Air Chief Marshal Arup Raha told the Hindustan Times that a deal for the Rafale is “going to happen soon.” Industry watchers in Delhi however say that there will be growing pressure to reconsider France given the volte-face the country made this week when it came to the supply of the Mistral ships to Russia.

Come clean on ties with Agusta: India to Dassault

With the defence ministry all set to blacklist Agusta-Westland-Finmeccanica for the VVIP helicopter bribery scandal, it has asked French aircraft manufacturer Dassault to clarify whether the Anglo-Italian chopper company was supplying parts for its Rafale medium multi-role combat aircraft (MMRCA) slated to be acquired by India at the cost of $20 billion.
India, US, China, Russia, Korea, Japan, UK, Germany, France, Pakistan, Defence news, DARPA, HAL, NATO, Israel, Afghanistan, Philippines, Dassault, MMRCASouth Block sources said the ministry wanted to seek prior clarification from Dassault during the negotiation stage as it did not want to face legal or operational hurdles for spare parts after the 126-aircraft deal had been signed.

“Dassault has been asked whether Agusta-Westland-Finmeccanica was original equipment manufacturer for the Rafale MMRCA as there were reports on the same. We have pointed out to Dassault that India was involved in litigation with the Anglo-Italian company over charges of bribery in the 12 VVIP helicopter purchase scandal,” said a senior defence ministry official.

When contacted, an Indian representative of Dassault said on condition of anonymity that Rafale was 100% French and the helicopter company was not part of original equipment supplier for the MMRCA.

While defence minister AK Antony is awaiting a CBI report on the VVIP helicopter scandal before formally blacklisting Agusta-Finmeccanica, there is pressure from within the services to delay the process, as the Anglo-Italian company supplies spare parts for US Apache and Chinook helicopters, which India is seeking to acquire from Washington.

The pressure from the services is quite evident, as the Italian helicopter company was inadvertently invited to Indian Defexpo in Delhi this month. But the fees, running into several crores of rupees, was refunded and invitation withdrawn after the ministry intervened at the highest levels.

“We want Dassault to clarify in writing that the helicopter company has nothing to do with MMRCA as there could be spare parts problems in future as under the rules defence ministry cannot deal with a company mired in bribery allegations in a contract,” said a senior official. The MMRCA deal is still a work in progress and will be signed by the next government.

Thales, BEL to form Joint Venture Company for Radars

The French aerospace company Thales and India’s Bharat Electronics Ltd. (BEL) have announced a joint venture to produce civil and military applications radars.
India, US, China, Russia, Korea, Japan, UK, Germany, France, Pakistan, Defence news, DARPA, HAL, NATO, Israel, Afghanistan, Philippines, Thales, BEL, MMRCA, Dassault, Eurofighter, Dassault RafaleAccording to a press statement issued by the two companies Aug 29, the two companies have taken this decision as a follow-up to the bilateral Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) signed on 17 Nov 2009 to set up a Joint Venture Company (JVC) to manufacture radars for India and foreign markets. The JVC will be “dedicated to the design, development, marketing, supply and support of civilian and select defence radars for Indian and export customers.” Thales will have 26 per cent share as allowed by the Indian foreign investment rules and BEL 74 percent.

The governing boards of both the companies have approved the formation, and procedural paperwork would now be submitted to the governments of India and France for approval. “The parent companies aim at making the Joint Venture Company a centre of excellence with the ability to offer solutions specifically aimed at meeting the needs of both Indian and export customers,” the statement said.

No timeline was specified. Notably, the state-run BEL has become the prime Indian company for producing electronic warfare and civil application systems, and a majority of contracts under the offsets and technology transfer programmes are likely to go to it.

And Thales is a big, French and global technology leader for Defence, Security, Aerospace and Transport sectors.Significantly, most of the electronic warfare systems, radars and weapons on board the Dassault Rafale aircraft are made by Thales. The AESA combat radar, a key requirement in the Indian MMRCA (Medium Multi Role Combat Aircraft) tender, has also been developed and demonstrated by Thales for this aircraft.

Rafale cleared the technical trials along with the European consortium’s Eurofighter but became the lowest bidder in financial terms. Discussions are on between Dassault, the aircraft manufacturer, and the Indian Ministry of Defence to settle the 50 percent offset package and the required ToT. Once the blanks have been filled in, the contract is likely to be signed, possibly by year end. Thales should derive some offsets benefits from its tieups with BEL, and other Indian companies, public or private sector.

Thales generated revenues of €13 billion (equivalent of $18.2 billion) last year. It has 67,000 employees in more than 56 countries, 22,500 engineers and researchers.

BEL offers products and services in Radars, Military Communications, Naval Systems, Electronic Warfare Systems, C4I Systems, Telecommunications, Sound and Vision Broadcasting, Opto-Electronics, Tank Electronics, Solar Photovoltaic Systems, Embedded Software and Electronic Components.

BEL is playing an important role in setting up secure communications for the Indian armed forces.

Send us a message

Story tips, corrections, questions or advertising enquiries: fill in the form and our team will reply by e-mail.

Newsletter

Stay Updated with Defense News

Get breaking defense and security news, analysis and exclusive reports delivered straight to your inbox.

Contact the newsroom

Have a defense story or an update to report?

Send us a news tip, a correction or a press release. Every message is read by our desk.