Text size
DefenseNewsGlobal Security.
Strategic Insight.
Breaking News

IAF can’t afford delay in Rafale deal : IAF Chief

Air chief marshal Arup Raha has said that it is critical to keep the $25 billion (Rs 1,50,000 crore) French Rafale fighter deal on schedule as the IAF cannot afford any more delays.

Raha’s comments are significant as the Eurofighter consortium, backed by four European countries, is trying to re-enter the race to sell its Typhoon fighters to India.

The Germany-led consortium has come up with a revised proposal -- sweetened with a discount -- to sell 126 Typhoons to India, despite losing the world’s biggest fighter contract to Dassault Aviation, which makes the Rafale fighter, two-and-a-half years ago.

In an exclusive interview to HT, Raha said, “It will not be appropriate to make any changes in the process. The current government has set the pace of work and things are moving fast enough on the fighter deal.”

The IAF chief refused to set a deadline for signing the Rafale deal but said “it’s going to happen soon”. India had selected Rafale fighters over Typhoons in January 2012 after Dassault Aviation emerged as the lowest bidder.

“Rafale has run through the finish line. It’s too late in the day to parachute into the race. The door is closed,” a senior defence ministry official said on the counteroffer made by the European consortium.

If India were to sign the Rafale deal today, the IAF will induct the last of the 126 fighters only by 2025. The acquisition is crucial as China is modernising its air force at a ripping pace.

The official said there was no provision in defence procurement rules to re-open the fighter competition at this stage to the consortium -- backed by Germany, the UK, Italy and Spain. It can make a comeback only if India is willing to scrap the deal and start from scratch.

The process of buying advanced fighters began in 2001, leading to the defence ministry floating a global tender to six foreign vendors in August 2007.

The consortium had made a counteroffer to the United Arab Emirates to sell 60 Typhoons but talks to seal the deal collapsed last December. It was competing with Rafale for the UAE order.

5th-generation fighter plan hits hurdle as Russia hikes cost

India's biggest defence project in the making, the critical joint development of the fifth-generation fighter aircraft (FGFA) with Russia, has flown into some rough weather.
India’s biggest defence project in the making, the critical joint development of the fifth-generation fighter aircraft (FGFA) with Russia, has flown into some rough weather.

Defence ministry sources said the inking of the final design and R&D contract for the stealth fighter has been hit by a huge delay, with Russia also jacking up costs for the futuristic project. “It’s very unlikely the FGFA final design contract will be concluded in the 2013-2014 fiscal,” said a source.

This contract was to be inked in 2012 as per the then revised timeline after completion of the preliminary design contract (PD C) phase. India will eventually end up spending close to $35 billion over the next two decades to induct over 200 such “swing-role” fighters.

The plan till last year was that India would begin inducting the FGFA from 2022 onwards, with IAF test pilots getting three prototypes in 2014, 2017 and 2019 for trials at the Hindustan Aeronautics manufacturing facility at Ozar.

“The timeframes will now have to be revised. MoD has established a committee of specialists and finance officials to verify the rise in costs. An internal contract negotiation committee is also in progress,” said the source.

But India remains firm about rejecting the US offer for joining its Joint Strike Fighter (JSF) or the F-35 ‘Lightning-II’ programme. “A lot of money and time has been invested in the FGFA with Russia. India simply cannot afford two FGFAs, both financially as well as logistically” he said.

The 18-month PDC worth $295 million for the FGFA with Russia was inked in December 2010, under which Indian designers and scientists have even been stationed in Russia to work out the blueprints and documentation for the fighter.

Though the Indian “perspective multi-role fighter” will be based on the Russian single-seat FGFA called Sukhoi T-50 or PAK-FA, which now has four prototypes flying, it will be tweaked to IAF requirements. IAF had initially pitched for 166 single-seat and 48 twin-seat fighters but will go for only single-cockpit jets now to reduce costs as well as protect stealth features.

The final design contract now being negotiated was pegged at $11 billion, with India and Russia sharing $5.5 billion each towards the cost of designing, infrastructure build-up at Ozar, prototype development and flight testing. Each fighter was to cost over $100 million.

IAF is quite confident the T-50 will meet its future requirements. Apart from ultra-manoeuvrability and supersonic cruising ability, the FGFA will carry its weapons inside the fuselage to lower its radar signature. With a cruising speed of Mach 1.7 to 1.8, it has both long-range strike and high-endurance air defence capabilities.

IAF is currently making do with just 34 fighter squadrons (each has 14 to 18 jets) despite needing at least 44 to keep both Pakistan and China at bay. It’s banking upon the ongoing induction of 270 Russian Sukhoi-30MKIs for around $12 billion as well as the early inking of the almost $20 billion project to acquire 126 French Rafale fighters to plug operational gaps till the FGFA becomes a reality.

Rafale deal is progressing, not bogged down : Indian Minister

The $12 billion contract for 126 multi-role medium range combat aircraft that India has awarded to French aircraft maker Dassault for its Rafale aircraft has not got bogged down in any controversy nor were certain issues holding it up, Minister of State for Defence Jitinder Singh has said.

The $12 billion contract for 126 multi-role medium range combat aircraft that India has awarded to French aircraft maker Dassault for its Rafale aircraft has not got bogged down in any controversy nor were certain issues holding it up, Minister of State for Defence Jitendra Singh has said.

“It is not stuck anywhere. It is the biggest deal of its kind in the world and, of course, a very complex one too. They are talking to HAL and the private sector companies in India as well; so it is progressing,” Jitinder Singh told IANS in an interview on the sidelines of the 50th Paris Air Show.

Rafale had last January emerged the winner of the Indian Air Force (IAF) tender, fighting off stiff competition from five other jets. Protracted price negotiations are currently under way as issues like life cycle costs and transfer of technology terms need to be factored in.

Indian officials had often said they hoped to wrap up the deal in the 2012-13 fiscal that ended March 31. However, with less than a year to go for the general election, the issue is likely to be decided only by the new government. The elections are due in Arpil-May 2014 but could be advanced depending on the evolving political scenario.

According to Jitinder Singh, France and India “have been working on a relationship which is not only aimed at enhancing the capabilities of our defence forces but also helping build up capacity in our defence industry, in both the public and private sectors”.

He said the focus of the Indian government was to push ahead with indigenous defence production, through both the public and private sectors.

“India has a great potential and could become a hub for defence production. We have the talent, we have the capabilities, now all we need is technology for that to happen. The ministry, in its 2013 Defence Procurement Policy, has taken the steps to facilitate the involvement of both the public and private sectors in defence production,” he said.

The Paris Air Show, Jitinder Singh said, “has once again demonstrated that there is a great deal of enthusiasm not only among French companies but also among others around the world to work with India as they have realised that the country is one of the biggest markets for them globally”.

“One of my key objectives during this visit is to meet various global defence companies and try and understand their problems and the roadblocks that they face in doing business with India so that the government can take appropriate steps to remove these,” said Jitinder Singh, who visited the Paris Air Show on Wednesday, accompanied by a high-level team from his ministry.

“Another objective is to ensure that India gets the best of the technology that exists, through the transfer of technology route,” he added.

The Paris Air Show “represents a great opportunity for all the participating countries and companies to meet their counterparts and partners and also for India, especially in terms of the France-India relationship which has clearly moved beyond the traditional buyer-seller level in the last few years,” Jitinder Singh told IANS.

He visited some of the key traditional defence partners of India, including the European aerospace giant EADS, during his quick tour of arguably the world’s largest air show.

Jitinder Singh would also be meeting French Defence Minister Jean Yves Le Drian to discuss various dimensions of bilateral ties.

Send us a message

Story tips, corrections, questions or advertising enquiries: fill in the form and our team will reply by e-mail.

Newsletter

Stay Updated with Defense News

Get breaking defense and security news, analysis and exclusive reports delivered straight to your inbox.

Contact the newsroom

Have a defense story or an update to report?

Send us a news tip, a correction or a press release. Every message is read by our desk.